In search of the Perfect Meatball
With a desire to run down my inventories of frozen high-quality Angus certified beef steaks it was naturally a brilliant idea to grind it down and make meatballs. Why not experiment by cooking the meatballs Sous Vide.
I have always felt that meatballs were a peasant dish, and also highly abused by American cuisine that tends to slather them with cheap canned tomato sauce and plonk them atop over-cooked pasta. I wanted to give meatballs more credit.
After an exhaustive survey of the internet for an authentic Italian meatball recipe I decided on the following for my base recipe: Beef, Parsley, Egg, Garlic, parmigiano-reggiano, Potato, salt and pepper. I decided to experiment with four other recipes in addition to the base: 1) base+ricotta; 2) base+spanish smoked paprika+prosciutto+nutmeg 3) base+young goats cheese+toasted pine nuts 4) Mongrel: 1+2+3
1. Preparing the base recipe: Mince the beef with a very sharp knife. Chop the remainder of the ingredients then mix! I used a food-mill to rice the potato. Place balls in zip-loc bags
2. Fill each bag with oil and place in water-bath for a few hours at 134degrees. These bags were not vacuum sealed. I used the oil-displacement method as vacuum sealing will ruin the malleable balls.
3. Remove from the water-bath and sear at high temperature for one-minute
4. The results below. Unfortunately the pine-nut and goats cheese ball had poor structural integrity.
CONCLUSION: I very much like the base ball (top right), followed by the ball on the bottom right with paprika and nutmeg. I tasted no difference with the addition of ricotta. The pine-nut and goats cheese ball was good, but perhaps I will not try this again. The use of potato instead of breadcrumbs left a very unique texture that I am not sure that I liked. Next time I will settle on the base meatball recipe with the addition of nutmeg and paprika.
We are not finished yet. How about cooking the balls the traditional way? Pan-fry followed by a few minutes in the oven. How does it compare to the Sous-vide ball?
The traditional cooking method are on the left of the photo. Unfortunately it was hard to tell the difference in texture of flavor between the two. It is my conclusion that it is not worth the effort of sous-vide for meatballs.